RAIDER925, don't worry about them charging you the games. They will not do that. From what I was told by the customer rep is that the system will automatically flag your account and put a hold on it if it determines that too many games are being lost. The worst that can happen is that they revoke your account. They will not charge you for the missing games because they cannot prove that you kept them or they really got lost in the mail. They will still send another game as usual when filing a shipping problem with Gamefly. As for USPS, they will take your name, address, and destination address and the company name if applicable. They will then give you a confirmation number which you should keep for your records and provide to Gamefly if necessary. I sent them my confirmation number as proof that I actually filed a complaint with USPS. Personally, after I filed a complaint with USPS, I have not had one game lost yet....we'll see how long this keeps up. Gamefly is aware that it is not our fault if the game gets lost, so they will not charge us for the game, but they also told me that they want to "protect" their business and may cancel the subscription because they are losing money for the games that get lost. But, he did say that it usually takes quite a bit of games being lost in a short period of time in order for the system to actually flag the account. I have had 4 lost games within the last 3 months and I still have a "good standing" status with them.
~Jason