This is a common problem and it's really "defective by design".
When you buy an XBLA game (or any XBL content for that matter) it attaches itself to your profile on MS's XBL servers and it attaches itself to the motherboard in your console; presumably the content itself gets infused with something that identifies which console it belongs to (some kind of serial number I assume).
That means that the only way for the console to validate that the content you've purchased actually belongs to you it must either
A. connect to the Xbox Live servers and see that the gamertag is on the list of approved owners for the content
or
B. check the console code embeded in the content and see if it matches the console it's being played on.
MS sent you a different console (or at least a different mobo) so option A is the only way it can validate.
As of right now the ONLY solution is the following
1. Create a new XBL Silver account on your console
2. Call MS and convince them to credit that account the amount of MS points needed to re-purchase all of your content.
3. Delete all of the content from your hard drive
4. Use that new Silver account to repurchase/redownload all of your content.
This will associate all the redownloaded content with your new console. Since your current GT has already purchased all the content it's still associated with that. Alternatively you can cut MS out of the loop and simply buy all of your content again.
If you bought a new console and had this problem MS can claim no responsibility. However since MS "repaired" your console and broke your content in the process they should be held responsible for it, I know they've helped others in this situation with the above procedure.
These are some scenarios I know others have been faced with that MS was sympathetic to:
-You don't have the console in a location where you can connect to the internet and you bring it to a friends house for updates and downloads. Now you can't use the stuff you purchased.
-You have children and there are certain XBLA games you allow them to play but you don't want them logging in your account as that would allow them access to M rated games as well as free reign of your credit card to make unauthorized XBLA purchases.
-If they give you crap tell them if you're not satisfied by the end of the conversation you're considering calling the Better Business Bureau.
-If they do still give you crap after that... you SHOULD seriously consider contacting the BBB.
GOOD LUCK (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/beerchug.gif)
This post has been edited by twistedsymphony: Apr 5 2007, 03:36 PM