Print

[yaazz]

Where to start on this one......
 
 Problem #1: Since you hold this thing like a shield, It doesn't resemble a real guitar whatsoever anymore
 Problem #2: There is only 4 fret buttons...
 Problem #3: Unless you can flip the thing upside down, lefties are out in the cold
 Problem #4: The DS has enough room for like 20 songs, meaning very little replay value
 Problem #5: If you are holding the ds with your right hand, and strumming with the left, you are effectively                        blocking the screen with the incoming notes!
 Problem #6: What about those of us who prefer the original DS?
 
 
 and don't even get me started on the comercial.....

[throwingks]

#1 So? You still play it like one.
#2 Just like a bass.
#3 You can probably flip it over. Many games incorporate this. Brain Age, Hotel Dusk, etc.
#4 Depending on the quality they are shooting for, they can fit as many songs on as they like. They could even sell the stand-alone cartridge if they want. If they were smart, they would have the game data on the GBA slot, and the song data on the DS slot. They probably wont do that though.
#5 As with the rumble pack, I wouldn't be surprised if you were left out, or had to order special. Even if nothing was available, I am sure a 3rd party accessory would show up.

[yaazz]

Actually, I was thinking they could use the GBA slot for executable code as well....  and I suppose if the quality were put to 64kbps or less it could hold a decent amount of songs. But I think i'll stick with jam sessions

[grim_d]

QUOTE(throwingks @ Mar 27 2008, 04:50 PM)

#2 Just like a bass.

basses have just as many frets as guitars lol, you are thinking strings, and even so, basses can have as many (and more) strings than guitars.

[yaazz]

plus bass, if we aren't playing 70's porno music, just isn't very exciting to play in guitar hero

[throwingks]

Epic Fail

[DanteDx]

A game like this on the DS will have some fail but it will also Be kinda of kool to see what they deliver. They have already said that it will work with both DS models. as for how many songs I would assume that since you have to have the fret piece then they would possibly put song and/or game data on that to get more songs into the game. I for one am going to buy this cause I like it when companys try some thing different.

[sabbath_dude]

Looks like fun.

[Mikesshunk]

Their design takes away the whole novelty of playing guitar hero. Something like this would be better:

[yaazz]

Whats black and white and red all over?

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Someone rolling down a hill attempting to play Guitar Hero DS with the device Mikesshunk drew above me

[JordanQ]

QUOTE(sicknasty413 @ Mar 27 2008, 05:54 PM)

@ the first post... as a righty, I feel more screwed over this.. because when I play GH, I hit the fret buttons with my left hand.. clearly this is made for a lefty. lol

what are you talking about?

you hold the ds in the palm of your left hand (and press the fret buttons)

you hold the back/bottom of the ds as if its the neck of the "guitar"

and strun the string of the ds.

[Mikesshunk]

QUOTE(yaazz @ Apr 17 2008, 04:11 AM)

Whats black and white and red all over?

.

.




Someone rolling down a hill attempting to play Guitar Hero DS with the device Mikesshunk drew above me

Someone had the same idea as me!