QUOTE(davinator456 @ Jun 21 2006, 03:22 PM)
i posted a topic about this game a little while back, it has mine and other's opinions
http://forums.xbox-s...howtopic=516772as the title states, i think it sounds pretty good.
however i remain undecided, a demo or rental will sway me one way or the other.
anyway, i think you are focusing on the wrong parts of the trailer- it looks OK, not phenominal but i think your just nitpicking things here... so the smoke doesn't stay that long...? are you going to just sit in battle and stare at burning carnage and smoke? no your going to blow something up and move outta the way and go onto the next target. and the buildings not piling up rubble? yes its somewhat dissapointing, but does this make the game look crappy? no. its just a mech game, not a building demoliton simulation or a smoky bonfire screensaver/digital fireplace that you can sit and sit and sit- staring at smoke all day.
you are a huge customizable robot- that runs around and blows up other huge customizable robots, sounds pretty cool to me, smoke or no smoke.
I'm not saying the game won't be fun. I will probably still pick it up, and I'm betting the online portion of it will rock regardless of any graphical issues.
What I am saying however, is that it just seems to be piss-poor design on their part to have things behave in such a way. Hell, let the wreckage fade after a little bit, but leave some at least. I mean, you blow up a tank, and if you look closely, you see a tire (?) in the explosion, then once the smoke clears after 2 seconds, there's nothing left. No sign there was ever even a battle there. No holes in the ground, no wreckage, not even freaking scorched ground!
As far as the smoke goes, personally I think it's a wonderful effect. But they should have made it last longer, to obstruct visiona bit more. It would be so cool, to have 2 mechs coming to you, and you fire a barrage of missles at the lead one, and due to all the smoke, you can't tell if he's fallen or not. Then after a couple of seconds, you see the 2nd one pop through the smoke, and begin barring down upon you. In otherwords, it could have been used immersively. But as it is now, it's just eye candy.
But as you say, the focus on the game is about mech battles, and customization. As far as the battles are concerened, I'm sure they'll be alot of fun. And I'm sure there's a ton of stuff you can do to outfit your mech. So, yeah, roughly the 2 biggest areas of hype should be covered.