You don't get signal loss with the advance A/V pack... The composite and S-video are on seperate channels. Besides, when s-video output is enabled, so is composite. doesn't matter if you hook something up to the connection or not (or even if the connection is there), the xbox outputs to that connection. If there is any signal loss, you won't be able to tell, because it's always there.
QUOTE(xboxbox451 @ Apr 20 2005, 01:08 PM)
I'm curious as to the quality of the debug capture method. Does anyone have a captured segment they can post or a link to hosted segments?
Thanks for the links.
I'm not that crazy about the definition, like you said too jagged. But the coloring is good.
Do you know if it lost definition due to compression, or is that the way it actually records?
QUOTE(-FourDoor- @ Apr 21 2005, 03:33 PM)
xboxbox451: You're the same guy that posted on the AVS forums. I remember your comparison pics. Anyways, like I said in AVS, the only reason I went with composite in to the TV and svid to the pc as opposed to splitting svid all together was because I didn't want to spend $50 on the svid amplified splitter. If I want better PQ, then I plug in the HD AV pack instead to get 480p and not record the games. Besides, svid and composite in looks just as bad to me on my set.
QUOTE(xboxbox451 @ Apr 21 2005, 01:46 PM)
You must have one crappy TV not to notice the difference between s-vid and composite. On my TV, S-Vid is clearer, brighter, sharper, and much more defined than composite. The difffernce is night & day.
Maybe I'm giving s-video a bit too much credit, but I feel it renders text and images a bit sharper, proof being in the photos below and when it comes to recording, every little bit helps.

I finished expanding the recording tutorail linked in my sig to include an amplified method, among other things. I took four door's advice and added a part describing the use of an Advance AV pack, though I did not illustrate its installation since I never used one.
If anyone has a problem viewing the tut or sees a mistake pm me. thanks.