xboxscene.org forums

Xbox360 Forums => Xbox360 Hardware Forums => Xbox360 Audio/Video Technical => Topic started by: nfs911 on November 25, 2005, 07:33:00 AM

Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: nfs911 on November 25, 2005, 07:33:00 AM
On xbox 1, I got these $59.99 AV cables from Monster Cables. The picture didn't look any better and then I returned them the next day. I guess it depends on your setup.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: chochamu on November 25, 2005, 09:21:00 AM
i was wondering because with my setup i wan't to max out quality and especially sound becasue of the 5.1 for every game the 360 has. Right now i run the composite wires to a switch box and then from there they go to my projector. a nice 8 foot wide screen to play on is great but anyhow, will the monster composite cables lose any benefits once they reach the switch box?
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: eversio11 on November 25, 2005, 10:53:00 AM
QUOTE(chochamu @ Nov 25 2005, 10:28 AM) View Post

i was wondering because with my setup i wan't to max out quality and especially sound becasue of the 5.1 for every game the 360 has. Right now i run the composite wires to a switch box and then from there they go to my projector. a nice 8 foot wide screen to play on is great but anyhow, will the monster composite cables lose any benefits once they reach the switch box?

That has seriously got to be the worst connection setup I have ever heard of. What kind of switch box are we talking about, one of those cheap plastic ones in the video game section?
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: redwolf on November 25, 2005, 04:10:00 PM
QUOTE(nfs911 @ Nov 25 2005, 04:40 PM) View Post

On xbox 1, I got these $59.99 AV cables from Monster Cables. The picture didn't look any better and then I returned them the next day. I guess it depends on your setup.

there is "noticeable" improvements, but not worth to what they cost.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on November 26, 2005, 02:29:00 AM
You won't notice the difference, trust me.  Especially with YOUR setup.  The only reason I bought monster cable for my 1.0 was so I could have the optical out.  And since the 360 came with it, there is no need to buy the monster cables.  The only way you will see a difference in quality is if you are running 20 foot generic brand cables and switch to Monster's insulated cables.  But with an 8 foot cable, you won't see anything.  The cables that come with it are fine... ESPECIALLY for the composite cables.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on November 26, 2005, 11:58:00 PM
QUOTE(chochamu @ Nov 26 2005, 04:40 AM) View Post

no it is not a cheap plastic one from the video game section, this switch is made for hdtv and only has component inputs.

You just said you are running composite to a switch box... so which is it? Component or composite?

And just because it's "made for HDTV's" doesn't mean it isn't cheap...
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: eversio11 on November 27, 2005, 03:37:00 PM
QUOTE(chochamu @ Nov 27 2005, 03:39 PM) View Post

i'm using the component cables that came with the premium package sorry....

You asked about the composite monster cables. So you're using component cables now, but you want to know about the composite monster cables?
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on November 27, 2005, 08:05:00 PM
QUOTE(Sleeve @ Nov 27 2005, 03:05 PM) View Post

Wrap the conveyor belt in aluminum shielding, and a lot more filings get past the magnet undisturbed.  Wrap it with three layers and a decent gauge wire mesh, like Monster sells...

Don't forget the injected Nitrogen biggrin.gif , lol.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: MJFOSTER77 on November 27, 2005, 09:42:00 PM
Which is the best connection component or composite?
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on November 27, 2005, 11:46:00 PM
I don't know what kind of "high-end" systems you've seen, but it must have been an idiot who set it up because you can't really go too wrong with expensive unless it was put together horribly..  That's not to say you can't go right with cheap... but monster still makes fairly good quality cables.

The thing is, you have to have a REALLY good display to see any improvements just by switching to a certain brand or make of cable.  Hell, there was minimal difference in quality of picture switching from component to DVI on our 61" DLP.  Noticeable, but minimal.  Was it worth the extra 75 bucks to go to DVI? Yeah... I think so (if not for the quality, then for the peace of mind, lol).  But will it be worth it to you to spend an extra 50-70 to just switch to a "higher-end" version of what you already have? Probably not.  Unless, like already said, you're running 20+ ft of cable accross a room that may carry alot of interference straight from one device to the display, I don't see the need to spend more money.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: skylined on November 28, 2005, 12:18:00 PM
yea dude, u need to change your set up. screw that. but as far as the monster cables are concerened in your set up it's like putting something nice in a shitty car. but since i have a totally sweet set up i'd get em. not cause it would help w/ image and audio quality but because since i have so many electronic components running through my entertainment system their is a lot of electrical radiation and the monster cables are highly shielded to prevent stray signals from intering the cable and fucking up your signal.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: zombie4rave on November 29, 2005, 07:59:00 AM
This is just my opinion which will probably make some people mad but whatever. I think Monster is the Bose of cables. The average person thinks Bose makes the best speakers because of their elaborate in store displays and great marketing but the truth is theres a lot of products out there that are better for less money. Its the same way with Monster. If you want to spend the money, yeah you'll be getting a good cable. I have a pretty high-end setup and have tried all different kinds of cabling. I really cant tell the difference between Monster and any other quality cable.  If youre talking about cheap, generic stuff from Walmart or Radio Shack then yeah, maybe youd notice. The cable options are a little more limited when it comes to consoles. If its really bugging you then buy the cable from a local store and return it if you dont see an improvement. Personally, I doubt you will.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: aepuppetmaster on November 29, 2005, 04:24:00 PM
well i have to say that monster cables are better.  i am getting the monster cable vga cables cuz i know they will be the best (and i'd rather pay 20$ more for quality that will last than something that will be cheaper but not as good, as 20 bucks over the 5 yrs of a console is not that much).  i do have a comperison to.  i was using my dads monster optical cable (from our nice setup downstair, but i needed to have the xbox in my room smile.gif ).  i bought a cheap 12$ optical cable online and i thought i'd put them side by side and see how the light looked.  the cheap cable was hazzed over, but the monster remianed crystal clear (with the white light).  Well i have not tested out the sound quality to see if i noticed a diffrence (and for the optical it would have to be a lot to justify the 60$ i would have to spend) i did notice that the monster cable's quality did rock.
Edit: My bad the optical cable would have only been like 20-30$ more,  maybe when i get some $$$  beerchug.gif
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: tuknuh on November 29, 2005, 11:09:00 PM
avsforum.com

anything under 6 feet won't make a difference... even the crapiest cables will match the image quality of high end ones...

with that said...

check out monoprice.com ... that's probably the lowest price you're going to find on "good" cables... best place for dvi cables...

and yes, monster is way marked up... $100 cables really worth $20... etc...  same sh*t with bose ... don't believe the marketing... and don't believe salespeople... (e.g. monster cables is best buy's biggest profit return...)
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on November 30, 2005, 11:45:00 AM
QUOTE(aepuppetmaster @ Nov 29 2005, 03:31 PM) View Post

the cheap cable was hazzed over, but the monster remianed crystal clear (with the white light).

Did you put a flashlight to it or something?  The light that gets transmitted is red, not white.


And of course Best Buy is going to have expensive cables... that's what they're known for.  They'll keep their electronics at a decent price while they'll rape you with cables.  Stick to online retailers and ebay for that kind of stuff.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: aepuppetmaster on November 30, 2005, 05:21:00 PM
QUOTE(Owtlaw333 @ Nov 30 2005, 10:52 AM) View Post

Did you put a flashlight to it or something?  The light that gets transmitted is red, not white.

well i put one end to my light and saw.  i also put it to diffrent sold color areas (sam of course) on my monitors(lcd) and saw how it did.  it was informal, but i was convinced.  on another note tho, i was not able to notice a sound diffrence when i used that one, maybbe cuz of my system.  it also maybe cuz i was playing pdz, not really paying atention and it was not like dvd quality audio.    beerchug.gif
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on December 01, 2005, 01:52:00 PM
QUOTE(zombie4rave @ Dec 1 2005, 08:21 AM) View Post

Its light man. You either have it or you dont. Theres not going to be any sound difference in optical cables. Either it works or it doesnt. The only differences are going to be in the construction/duribility of the cable.

Umm.. no.  The quality of light matters.  Over a certain length (just like any cable) the light degrades/fades.  Also, some cables are just shit... foggy, or scratched outta the box.  When the lights is disrupted by scrathes or fades, there's a loss in quality.  Yes, if it is too disrupted, it will just not work, but there is a loss of quailty with anything less.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: zombie4rave on December 01, 2005, 02:54:00 PM
QUOTE
Umm.. no. The quality of light matters. Over a certain length (just like any cable) the light degrades/fades. Also, some cables are just shit... foggy, or scratched outta the box. When the lights is disrupted by scrathes or fades, there's a loss in quality. Yes, if it is too disrupted, it will just not work, but there is a loss of quailty with anything less.


The cable would have to be very long to create any kind of loss problems. Youre talking about a 6 to 12 foot cable in most cases. Loss shouldnt be a big problem unless the cable is VERY poor. If there is a scratch then you have a bad cable. Thats a given. If the signal is marginal error correction will kick in on your equiptment. If its too poor for the error correction to overcome then yes, you will hear it but it will be clicks, dropouts or digital noise. There will be audible errors. It wont be the type of situation where you can say one sounds better than another. If the light was distrupted completely or intermittenly youd lose your signal. But if its getting through at least reasonably well you'll never know the difference. If youre hearing clear sound you have a good cable. I still say the biggest difference is going to be duribilty. How it reacts to bends and aging. Its not going to be something like 'this one lets the light through easier so it sounds better." If youre talking copper cabling then theres much more room to argue but with optical any decent quality, undamaged cable is as good as the next. If you dont believe me, try it.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: Owtlaw333 on December 01, 2005, 10:01:00 PM
QUOTE(zombie4rave @ Dec 1 2005, 02:01 PM) View Post

The cable would have to be very...............

Exactly what I was sayin'... minus the in depthness of ur post, lol.  I aggree that durability should come first in choosing a cable because chances are that any cable will work just dandy outta the box. (Hell, I still use a cheap RadioShack cable I got way back when for the PS2)  I've only heard of one person getting a scratched cable right out of the package.
Title: Are Monster Cables Worth It?
Post by: zombie4rave on December 02, 2005, 06:04:00 AM
No disrespect meant Owtlaw. I think we might actually agree for the most part.  happy.gif