the whole term is meaningless anyways. every new game in the genre can be considered the "killer" of the former "king" in that genre as long as it holds up to the standards and beats them in some respects. however that title would only be held until the next "killer" came along which could very well be the first title that held that title. basically even if saint row ends up being the GTA killer i see nothing wrong with that as it should push rockstar into building an even better game and retaking the crown as the best game in the free-roam genre. every new title can be considered the killer until the next new one comes out, so in the end its all trivial.
What exactly makes this game a total copy? Has anyone of you saying that ever read anything about this game? Before you reply think about your answer, most of the things people say that make this a total copy can be said about alot of other games. In one of the dev interviews some dev makes the point that a few years ago every FPS was a DOOM copy but now they are simply FPSs and that is what they are trying to do with this game. I know this game has alot of things similar to GTA but why does that make it a clone. COD is like MOH but i dont hear that being called a clone. What does it have to have in order to not be a clone? Its not mission based, its got online, its got a different control scheme and different gameplay mechanics (all according to devs). What more does it need? I am not a huge fan of these kind of games either I just dont see why people cant give it its "props".
^ OT. why do all these special olympic arguements always end up being about how someone spelled something? get over it, we all make typo's. we're not journalists.
anyways, back on topic.
I think this game looks like it will be fun. GTA rip-off or not. I like the fact that there is multiplayer. You can actually customize your character, and not just change his clothes and hair. You can customize his body type, skin color, hair, face, etc. You can't do that with GTA: SA. I like the idea of the "insurance fraud" mini game to make money. Throw yourself in front of cars, but if there are too many witnesses you dont get as much money. Anyways, I dont think this game will be a "GTA Killer" but it should be fun. I'll probably rent it b4 I buy it, but if they make it right it will be in my game library. And when the new GTA comes out, I'm sure I will be one of the first in line to get that. Wait, nah, I wont be in line, I work at Best Buy. I'll have it as soon as we get them in!
QUOTE(Carlo210 @ Oct 15 2005, 03:25 AM)

Xbox. I see slim differences between them which make buying more than one similar to buying NBA 2k6 and nba 2006 and Nba street 4.
Completely different games sir completely different... try playing them with an open mind and you too will see.
I thought this thread looked familiar.
Wow I just realized how long its been snice I posted!
Oh well back to lurking.
It's good the thread got bumped up.
I still anticipate that Saint's Row has what it takes to make it a kick-ass free roamer. It looked gorgeous already in october, was fully playable, had nice physics, multiplayer modes etc - only a few framerate issues seemed to keep it from being published.
Adding eight monts to developing and polishing a game that was almost ready can't really hurt it - Saints Row might bring us a vivid city that feels much more realistic than those low-poly low-res cardboard houses in GTA.
I could give a shit how it looks. As long as it's fun, I'm there.
Holy bumped threads batman!
Nothing will be a GTA killer,it started everything!
QUOTE(Booker T @ Feb 28 2006, 09:09 AM)

Nothing will be a GTA killer,it started everything!
exactly the reason Wolf 3D is the best FPS ever made.... better then Doom, Quake, GoldenEye, Halo, etc. etc. etc.
because being first automatically means you're the best right?
QUOTE(twistedsymphony @ Feb 28 2006, 05:54 PM)

exactly the reason Wolf 3D is the best FPS ever made.... better then Doom, Quake, GoldenEye, Halo, etc. etc. etc.
because being first automatically means you're the best right?
Touché.
How come people get to make football games, sidescrolling shooters, stragedy games, card games etc without constantly being compared to first c64 versions? But make a free-roamer and you're always automatically going to be worse than GTA. 
GTA is a great game, but it does have huge flaws, starting from crappy graphics to total lack of AI.