xboxscene.org forums

Xbox360 Forums => Xbox 360 General Forums => Xbox360's Multimedia Features => Topic started by: Devedander on January 08, 2009, 03:04:00 PM

Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Devedander on January 08, 2009, 03:04:00 PM
I'd be happy to get it for free or something but I don't want an external player or to be charged up the wazoo for it so I think they got me covered with "not high on the list of wants".
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: MickRaider on January 08, 2009, 03:07:00 PM
I think people would rather have digital download and cheaper larger hard drives.

There's really no reason it costs so much to increase your hard drive space.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Dark Seraph on January 08, 2009, 03:11:00 PM
QUOTE(MickRaider @ Jan 8 2009, 05:43 PM) View Post

I think people would rather have digital download and cheaper larger hard drives.

There's really no reason it costs so much to increase your hard drive space.

http://www.newegg.co...N82E16822116095

I would even agree with a 40$ markup because of the grey case around the hdd. lol. laugh.gif
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: twistedsymphony on January 08, 2009, 03:12:00 PM
What want to know is where is this "LIST" and how can let me voice be represented on it...
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Dark Seraph on January 08, 2009, 03:19:00 PM
QUOTE(twistedsymphony @ Jan 8 2009, 05:48 PM) View Post

What want to know is where is this "LIST" and how can let me voice be represented on it...

I want some of these
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: tom_mandory on January 08, 2009, 03:24:00 PM
I wouldnt like my blu-ray player to be unusable for weeks at a time while my 360 is at the repair centre for RROD.

So bach is right, Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: keystroke on January 08, 2009, 03:34:00 PM
QUOTE(GOVATENT @ Jan 9 2009, 09:59 AM) View Post

I call BS on microsoft. They never do what the people want. How many of us 360 owners would love to see a web browser on the 360. I would love a 360 add on, but knowing microsoft it would take me a lifetime to save up to buy one if it did come out.


if they release a browser the console will be hijacked straight away, it's not worth their time updating a browser when everyone has a PC Anywaqy.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Ranger72 on January 08, 2009, 03:34:00 PM
There is no need for one now. You can pick up a stand alone Blu-Ray player for a little over $100. Very soon they will be under $100. I know Microsoft would not bother making an external Blu-Ray addon unless they can charge at least $150 or more for it.

The next Xbox will have a Blu-Ray drive.

However this digital download is not the answer to blu-ray. I love using netflix on my 360 and I purchase HD movies from the video store on Live for a quick movie flick. But unless someone wants to download 50GB files every time they want a TRUE HD experience then blu-ray will be here to stay for a long time.

Watching a so called HD movie from a digital download is nowhere near the quality of a blu-ray movie.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: echto on January 08, 2009, 03:47:00 PM
QUOTE(GOVATENT @ Jan 8 2009, 02:59 PM) View Post

I call BS on microsoft. They never do what the people want. How many of us 360 owners would love to see a web browser on the 360. I would love a 360 add on, but knowing microsoft it would take me a lifetime to save up to buy one if it did come out.



What MS fails to mention is the 'list of people' they're talking about are the MS employees sitting around the meeting table.

Do you seriously think the greater portion of xbox 360 owners in the world would have put a game like "Lips" on the list of things the xbox360 should have !!!  I doubt it.

beerchug.gif

QUOTE(keystroke @ Jan 8 2009, 03:10 PM) View Post

if they release a browser the console will be hijacked straight away, it's not worth their time updating a browser when everyone has a PC Anywaqy.



All the traffic will have to go through MS servers.  Remember.... the traffic is encrypted.  A browser will never happen because of that.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: devguy on January 08, 2009, 03:54:00 PM
"When you ask people the list of things they want to see us spending time creating in Xbox, Blu-ray is way, way down on the list."

So I guess at one point in time HD-DVD was at the top of the list?
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: bucko on January 08, 2009, 04:17:00 PM
So Avatars are wanted by the xbox community? I would say Blu-Ray has more use.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Reaper527 on January 08, 2009, 04:30:00 PM
QUOTE(Dark Seraph @ Jan 8 2009, 05:55 PM) View Post

Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: halofun121 on January 08, 2009, 04:43:00 PM
I don't know where they get this stuff from. What he's really trying to say is "We don't feel like promoting our competitor's product." I'm sure people would buy an external Blu-ray drive if they knew what Blu-ray is. Hell, they wasted money on an external HD-DVD drive, I'm sure they'd make tons more on a Blu-ray one. I for one don't have any space for a standalone player, so something like this would really work out well.

If you're reading this Microsoft, I WANT ONE!
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Exobex on January 08, 2009, 05:00:00 PM
They could just add support for an external drive like this one, no need to market their own unit then.  Shouldn't cost much to develop the software, and it's a kick in the nads for Sony.  Not that I'll buy Sony again in any case, if I want a standalone Blu-Ray I'll buy a Panasonic.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Harteex on January 08, 2009, 05:17:00 PM
I just want a quiet Xbox360  dry.gif  Oh and a fix for the DPAD... Don't care that much about Blu-Ray yet.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Roupus on January 08, 2009, 05:21:00 PM
I wouldn't want a bluray player for the xbox to play movies. I would want it so games that are too big in size to fit on a dl dvd would fit nicely on a 50 gig bluray disc giving the gamers more content.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: DMAddict on January 08, 2009, 05:41:00 PM
Blu-ray is nonexistant on my list. With XBMC on Linux, who need Blu-ray. That said, I'll buy when the price drops below $50.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: InajaD on January 08, 2009, 06:56:00 PM
Well, I'd love to have a stand alone BD but I got tired of waiting for all rumors to become reality so I just got me a BD player. Now a MS stand alone is not on my list at all! Neither is a web browser! A very useless thing anyways.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Foe-hammer on January 08, 2009, 07:20:00 PM
QUOTE(steveju @ Jan 8 2009, 04:24 PM) View Post

I consider myself a Xbox 360 gamer and I wanted Blu-Ray so bad, I bought the PS3, because it was the cheapest player at that time.

My point is that sure, you can say that Xbox gamers don't want Blu-Ray anymore, because if they did, they would've purchased a PS3 or a stand-alone Blu-Ray player by now. I bet most people aren't so brand loyal that they wait untill Microsoft decides to come up with an addon to play Blu-Ray movies on it. That ship has sailed and Bach's comment is just a pathetic attempt to justify the absence of a Blu-Ray addon.

I second that.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: YLA G on January 09, 2009, 03:31:00 AM
QUOTE(g8crapachino @ Jan 9 2009, 01:45 AM) View Post

So tell them, where are all these people who want to browse the web on their 360's?   You're making assumptions without any facts and your personal opinion doesn't count for the majority.  Both the Wii and the Ps3 have web browsers and the number of people that use them to browse the net is pathetic at best.  

There's an article on new.spong.com about this, search for "PS3 Beats Wii on Internet Use".  The combined total for PS3 and Wii users using their consoles to browse the web is a paltry 0.05%.  There are more people using cells phones to browse the internet then there are game consoles.   In fact all previous attempts at TV based web browsing have proven to be complete failures. Given these real facts it's understandable why Microsoft isn't wasting their time to bring a browser to the the 360, there just isn't enough evidence to show that people would actually use it to make it worthwhile.


Euhm.. to all:

there is a difference between reel surfing (google, facebook, etc) and quickly checking news, weather on your big Full HD tv. So yes, I would like a thumb on the NXE to see the forecast, major nelson's RSS etc.. I am sure everyone would love it..
Indeed it never replaces a browser/pc but looking very fast to some info (also like walktroughs) is realy the future of your TV.

Anyway.. I buyed a Samsung bd-p1500 (there real cheap but good) but if there was an addon on my xbox tell me why I would'nt wanted that to buy??
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: MOE2FREAKY on January 09, 2009, 03:42:00 AM
QUOTE(steveju @ Jan 9 2009, 10:24 AM) View Post

I consider myself a Xbox 360 gamer and I wanted Blu-Ray so bad, I bought the PS3, because it was the cheapest player at that time.

My point is that sure, you can say that Xbox gamers don't want Blu-Ray anymore, because if they did, they would've purchased a PS3 or a stand-alone Blu-Ray player by now. I bet most people aren't so brand loyal that they wait untill Microsoft decides to come up with an addon to play Blu-Ray movies on it. That ship has sailed and Bach's comment is just a pathetic attempt to justify the absence of a Blu-Ray addon.

Can the 360 handle a blu ray player? HD-DVD (Video/Audio/Subs) max is 30.24 Mbit/s while the max bit rate for Blu-ray is 48 Mbit/s?(Got that from Wiki) All that over a USB cable. I remember reading somewhere an article a while ago that HD-DVD was pushing the 360. I could be wrong. Meh
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: johnnyrico on January 09, 2009, 03:58:00 AM
I call BS, here's my list:
-improved service for europeans, like a decent video marketplace instead of all that US exclusive discrimination bs, licensing my ass!

-improved codec support for media center extender
-bluray support(fuck that, I'm not buying a PS3 or another device for that, note how it's on place 3?)
-performance improvements to the dashboard
-NTFS support for USB drives
-improved XBL service
-price drop for arcade games and premium themes
-a decent way to use our old themes, get rid of that ugly grey floor and have different backgrounds for the my xbox, game marketplace, video marketplace and spotlight menus!
-RSS feeds on 360
-a browser
-more PC-360 interaction, why are there no games 360 owners can play online against PC users? sure racing games and RPG's shouldn't be a problem?
-more uses for the XBL vision camera
-PC drivers for the 360 wifi dongle!!!!
-chatpad support for the PC
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: MOE2FREAKY on January 09, 2009, 04:04:00 AM
QUOTE(johnnyrico @ Jan 9 2009, 10:34 PM) View Post

I call BS, here's my list:
-improved service for europeans, like a decent video marketplace instead of all that US exclusive discrimination bs, licensing my ass!

-improved codec support for media center extender
-bluray support(fuck that, I'm not buying a PS3 or another device for that, note how it's on place 3?)
-performance improvements to the dashboard
-NTFS support for USB drives
-improved XBL service
-price drop for arcade games and premium themes
-a decent way to use our old themes, get rid of that ugly grey floor and have different backgrounds for the my xbox, game marketplace, video marketplace and spotlight menus!
-RSS feeds on 360
-a browser
-more PC-360 interaction, why are there no games 360 owners can play online against PC users? sure racing games and RPG's shouldn't be a problem?
-more uses for the XBL vision camera
-PC drivers for the 360 wifi dongle!!!!
-chatpad support for the PC

^Agreed. Call me a whinger but I just want the D-Pad fixed. Getting ready for street fighter 4.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: sabbath_dude on January 09, 2009, 08:37:00 AM
Blu-ray doesn't interest me much and if it did I'd probably just buy a standalone unit over an external MS addon. You can pick up Blu-ray players for around £100 now and the prices are falling all the time. I doubt Microsoft could compete with that.

Higher on my list of 360 features I want would be a simple web browser for checking mail/news/weather/facebook/youtube etc from my couch. Sure I have a PC for proper browsing and typing etc but the convenience of a simple built in browser very much appeals to me. Other features I'd like to see are better codec support, a D-pad that works properly, the sluggish guide loading problems fixed and more choice to customise the NXE themes.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: gfxdreams on January 09, 2009, 09:51:00 AM
I would love to see this list. I'm sure if this list was posted there would be millions of hits and millions of opinions. the list would hit xbox-scene that day.

there would be a blue ray addon probally on the next generation xboxes. Or an Addon that would cost around $100-$150 i bet. these are just my opinions. None are facts I'v read.

It should be exciting to see what happens with the xbox since HD will soon be history.

-gfxdreans
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Martinchris23 on January 09, 2009, 01:20:00 PM
Whilst we can argue the fact of whether Blu-Ray is right for the 360, surely the point here is "who the Hell did they ask?". It was only in the last week that MS were bragging over 1.5 million Xbox Live users were concurrently signed in at any one time over Xmas (myself included), they surely have no excuse for a lack of a demographic market of 360 users? They see it fit to plague XBL and games (for which we pay for) with adverts for other products, yet something as useful as a poll cannot be published? This statement runs parallels for me of the school bully saying to the new kid "we don't want you as our friend", thinking they're speaking on behalf of the class.

I may or may not agree, but don't be putting words into my mouth. If I own a 360 and have an Xbox Live account, you can be sure I'm quite able to speak for myself. Next time you choose to reply on behalf of the 360 populous Mr Bach, be sure to actually ASK us.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: trentdadi on January 09, 2009, 02:46:00 PM
Last I heard, the HD-DVD add on saw a 2% attach rate and at the time was among the cheapest HD-DVD players as long as you already owned a 360.  The attachment rate for a stand-alone Blu-ray player would be even less.  Any add-on they make will be plagued by limitations.  A good portion of xbox 360s in people's homes do not even have HDMI ports.  It isn't impossible but it is very rare for a display device to be able to display 1080p over component.  I do not think that Dolby TrueHD or DTS-Master would even be possible.  There is just too many potential issues that would condemn the idea from the beginning.  It would just never be as good as a stand-alone player could be.  

I am not sure how anyone could know already if they would even want it or not.  Who knows what would be possible or the best case scenario specs would be.

If you really want a blu-ray player, just go buy the samsung one someone stated earlier, it's a fantastic player and imo you can never go wrong with samsung.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Zod5000 on January 09, 2009, 04:35:00 PM
Bluray is dropping in price. No need for an add-on, they'd be hard to compete against standalones.

I figure the next xbox would have bluray built in though, as they'll need the extra storage capacity.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: TMownsu on January 09, 2009, 04:59:00 PM
Ins't this the same people that told us we don't want HDMI? They should stop worring about what we want, & keep delivering like they have been.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: ubiman on January 09, 2009, 07:59:00 PM
QUOTE(TMownsu @ Jan 9 2009, 08:35 PM) View Post

Ins't this the same people that told us we don't want HDMI? They should stop worring about what we want, & keep delivering like they have been.

More like "Stop thinking and assuming what we want and actually listening and asking what we want."
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Grumbledock on January 10, 2009, 05:37:00 AM
Well, I would really like:

*A web browser, (even if ie sucks)
*Support for mkv, (with subtitles/mp4 with subtitles) etc.
*And of course a bluray, even a cheap one would do just untill the stand alone gets cheap enogh to be worth buying (next consol 2010, how many dvds per game until then, 5? 7? 9?)
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: Chancer on January 10, 2009, 05:50:00 AM
QUOTE(trentdadi @ Jan 9 2009, 10:22 PM) View Post

Last I heard, the HD-DVD add on saw a 2% attach rate and at the time was among the cheapest HD-DVD players as long as you already owned a 360.  The attachment rate for a stand-alone Blu-ray player would be even less.  Any add-on they make will be plagued by limitations.  A good portion of xbox 360s in people's homes do not even have HDMI ports.  It isn't impossible but it is very rare for a display device to be able to display 1080p over component.  I do not think that Dolby TrueHD or DTS-Master would even be possible.  There is just too many potential issues that would condemn the idea from the beginning.  It would just never be as good as a stand-alone player could be.

It could be better by far than a standalone player. never out of date. permanently upgradeable via software updates. It could be anything they wished it to be. The price would be the limiting factor
 
QUOTE(trentdadi @ Jan 9 2009, 10:22 PM) View Post

I am not sure how anyone could know already if they would even want it or not. ] Who knows what would be possible or the best case scenario specs would be.

Contradicts what you said above.

QUOTE(trentdadi @ Jan 9 2009, 10:22 PM) View Post

If you really want a blu-ray player, just go buy the samsung one someone stated earlier, it's a fantastic player and imo you can never go wrong with samsung.

 laugh.gif  Be honest you haven't got one. You wouldn't say you could never go wrong with Samsung if you had to service their warranty covered equipment. They are ok for the money but not top notch stuff.
ask any owner of one of their optical drives , how good the tray load mech is.?
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: manu_xl on January 11, 2009, 09:03:00 AM
in europe 90% still have a regular television. why would they like to have blueray if they cant watch the movies on a hdtv ?
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: HotKnife420 on January 11, 2009, 02:27:00 PM
QUOTE(keystroke @ Jan 9 2009, 12:10 AM) View Post

if they release a browser the console will be hijacked straight away, it's not worth their time updating a browser when everyone has a PC Anywaqy.


 I'm sick of these kind of responses. Nobody can prove that the browser would be hijacked right away (although I'm sure hackers would turn their attention towards it).

 The Wii & the PS3 BOTH come bundled with a web browser. Aside from that, there's firmware hacks for EVERY dvd-drive that appears in a 360, so don't gimme that "what about piracy" crap, because frankly, I don't see how it could get any easier. The Wii has several hacks and chips as well, but I haven't seen much complaining on Nintendo's side, as they're still selling wiis to everyone (except for people I know). If the web browser is a guaranteed "hijack", then how come there's still no way to run unsigned code on a PS3 (save installing another OS and having it's RSX gimped)?

 I'm not saying it would never happen, but it's just the worst arguement *not* to have a web browser.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: brando56894 on January 11, 2009, 03:37:00 PM
QUOTE(MickRaider @ Jan 8 2009, 05:43 PM) View Post

I think people would rather have digital download and cheaper larger hard drives.

There's really no reason it costs so much to increase your hard drive space.


there is a reason.... microsoft wants to screw you out of every single penny you have. for example $300-400 operating systems THAT YOU DONT LEGALLY OWN and $400 office suites. theyre in the business to make money not to satisfy consumer wants, which is a horrible business model but theyre able to do it since they have a huge market share.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: YLA G on January 12, 2009, 04:08:00 AM
QUOTE(manu_xl @ Jan 11 2009, 06:39 PM) View Post

in europe 90% still have a regular television. why would they like to have blueray if they cant watch the movies on a hdtv ?



lol where you from?

btw.. "how many % with an xbox 360 in europe have still a crt" is a more proper question
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: G19 on January 12, 2009, 04:30:00 AM
QUOTE(manu_xl @ Jan 11 2009, 04:39 PM) View Post

in europe 90% still have a regular television. why would they like to have blueray if they cant watch the movies on a hdtv ?


Of the dozen or so people that I know here in the UK with a 360 only 1 doesn't have access to at least a 720p capable set, with 5 of those 12 having a full 1080p set.

Personally I only have a 32" 720p LCD so BluRay wouldn't be worth the extra expense. When I get a bigger full HD set though I will buy a standalone. I would prefer an addon to the 360 if it was comparable in price/features.
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: hamwbone on January 12, 2009, 04:46:00 AM
i own a wii, a ps3 and a 360. i have a 65 inch tv. browing the web on my tv is just stupid... i got a wireless mouse and keyboard for my ps3 and tried using it, but it doesnt fit the bill. the fact that you cant even set up a netflix que on the 360 should give you an idea of how important a browser on the console is. its a waste of time, use your damn computer.....

rant off  tongue.gif

can some one explain to me what the big deal is about mkv? i have never played one before but the 360 had played things my ps3 spit back at me.  Divx was handing out (for free!!!) free divx pro serials a few months back, 100% legal, and use that to encode my shit, works fine. what is this mkv buisness though? (pardon my ignornace, hehe, i used to be a real nerd i swear!)
Title: Bach: Blu-ray Isn’t Wanted By Xbox Consumers
Post by: G19 on January 12, 2009, 07:44:00 AM
QUOTE(hamwbone @ Jan 12 2009, 12:22 PM) View Post

can some one explain to me what the big deal is about mkv? i have never played one before but the 360 had played things my ps3 spit back at me.  Divx was handing out (for free!!!) free divx pro serials a few months back, 100% legal, and use that to encode my shit, works fine. what is this mkv buisness though? (pardon my ignornace, hehe, i used to be a real nerd i swear!)


It's just a container like avi/mp4/mov etc, except that it has become pretty much the format of choice for HDTV caps and BD/HD DVD rips. Thus it is a very important format for a lot of people. It also offers advantages over other older container formats, and it would be a great move if we could play them natively, without the need for all the conversion/re-encoding crap.

http://matroska.org/