Found the following games to be thorughly enjoyable on Surreal64:
NHL '99
Emulator Version: Surreal 1.0
Rom Version: NHL 99 (U) [!] (.v64)
Rom Settings: [PJ64], Video=3, Dyna=20, Paging=6
1964, playable, but stuttering audio.
Project 64, near perfect. Flickers in in-game menu. Minimal slowdown. Average fps=22
UltraHLE, Not Tested
Premier Manager 64
Emulator Version: Surreal 1.0
Rom Version: Premier Manager 64 (E) [!] (.v64)
Rom Settings: [PJ64], Dyna=16, Paging=6
1964, playable, but some gfx errors in match highlights.
Project 64, near perfect. Unsynchronized AV in match highlights.
UltraHLE, Not Tested