Thanks for the suggestion, unfortunately it still doesn't work. It behaves the same way even when using true emulation. I load up the game by either pressing A or Right-Analog, then I press Left-Analog. It brings up the C64 Basic screen and says:
LOAD "*",8,1
READY.
RUN
READY.
That's exactly how it behaves. It never loads it properly. I guess I could try and look around and see if I can find another copy of this game. It is the standard size when compared to others. I was just curious if anyone else has seen this issue.