I'd like to weigh-in again here. I see a lot of the same guys in the 360 B/S/T trading...like omega2468 and celticsfan. All my experiences have been positive...but I am a cautious trader. A carless person will get taken at some point. There will be a certain group who will consistantly be trading (probably myself included). So there will be some comfort level and really solid referrences for a growing number of traders.
Let's say a newbie comes in and wants to trade, with no referrences. He contacts me for a trade, and I'm interested. All I do is tell him to PM my refs, and if he's still interested, he ships first.
Personal contact info-including real name, email, home address, and home phone-should always be available for both parties.
Lastly, like
twistedsymphony noted, it is sometimes hard to find game trades in the B/S/T. One has to sift through a few pages. I like HSD's idea of only trading games in there. If one has hardware, just list it in the B/S/T. The one problem I guess would be moderation. I don't know what kind of work it would take to keep the non-game trades out of there, since the pinned topics are frequently ignored. It might not be a problem, though...I don't know.
I'd still love to see a dedicated 360 game trade forum
