Print

[vidgms4me]

Personaly, I think that there is no way this will happen.  Post count does encourage people to continue posting.  Plus, if someone is getting mixed info and trying to judge who is right, it is much more reliablle to take info from someone with 2,000 posts, as opposed to someone with two.

Disabling post count would cause this place to be deserted.  Everyone already knows who the spammers are, and disabling post count would not discourage them one bit.

Well, that's my 2 cents.

[brahm2]

I think...

the problem is more in General Chat than it is with spammers. People just SPAM a lot. Remember the thread about "Help me get to 666"? That user's post count was reset back down to 6 after that stunt. Basically.. abuse the post count, lose the post count.

I think it's neat when people hit milestones (I guesstimate 10,000 posts for some by Xmas) such as 1000 or 500 and things like that. But, there is no need to dedicate a topic to your post count. Just add it into a thread somewhere, like this:

QUOTE

Yes, I am in favour/against the topic blah blah <edit> btw 1000 posts w00t!

^ thats okay because its not spamming; he made a point to the topic beforehand, etc etc

just my $.02

This post has been edited by brahm2: Sep 6 2003, 07:34 PM

[Videogamebuyer14]

Bad idea. Because then the newbies will get mixed up with the regulars, and there will be chaos. Keep the post count, I say!

[gainpresence]

The Head Moderators and Admins discussed this a while back, we basically shot it down to "Posting in the General Forums won't increase your post count".. Then we shot that down completely, we wouldn't want the General spammers migrating over to the sane forums

[Large Dopant white]

QUOTE (vidgms4me @ Sep 6 2003, 09:25 PM)

Personaly, I think that there is no way this will happen.  Post count does encourage people to continue posting.  Plus, if someone is getting mixed info and trying to judge who is right, it is much more reliablle to take info from someone with 2,000 posts, as opposed to someone with two. Disabling post count would cause this place to be deserted.  Everyone already knows who the spammers are, and disabling post count would not discourage them one bit. Well, that's my 2 cents.

Not true. There's been plenty of users, come and gone, that have postcount in the thousands that know less about the XBox than some retarded monkey who skimmed a few of the tutorials. On the other hand, I've seen users with less than a handful of posts who give wonderful advice and info because they don't spend their time jabbering- they spend it on actually using their XBox and reading the tutorials. Relying on the postcount at all is a bad idea, and it's really only there because it would seem *wrong* not to have it.... but I'm all for it to go away. It'd discorage more of the dumbass types from posting at all; postcount doesn't encourage true contributors from posting. You think Dmauro gives a damn about his? How about Ubergeek? The only people who give a damn about it are those who want to spend more time socially politicking than actually helping.

[EDIT] Guess I'm still rambling. Anyway, what would be wrong with the forums losing those who purely just want to post for the hell of it? If that's half the members, what would be wrong with the forums becoming less of a social stomping grounds and more like pure content? Isn't that what the forum was created for in the first place?[/EDIT]

[vidgms4me]

QUOTE (Large Dopant white @ Sep 6 2003, 05:17 PM)

Not true. There's been plenty of users, come and gone, that have postcount in the thousands that know less about the XBox than some retarded monkey who skimmed a few of the tutorials. On the other hand, I've seen users with less than a handful of posts who give wonderful advice and info because they don't spend their time jabbering- they spend it on actually using their XBox and reading the tutorials. Relying on the postcount at all is a bad idea, and it's really only there because it would seem *wrong* not to have it.... but I'm all for it to go away. It'd discorage more of the dumbass types from posting at all; postcount doesn't encourage true contributors from posting. You think Dmauro gives a damn about his? How about Ubergeek? The only people who give a damn about it are those who want to spend more time socially politicking than actually helping.

I agree with you 100%.  However, if you eliminated post counts, there would be no distinction at all.  I am well aware that post count does not affect quality advice.  Many newbies do give very good advice.  

However, many newbies are known to give incorrect advice.  Yes, there are people with high post counts that give bad advice.  

Oh well, I have no idea where I am going with my arguements.  Just please keep the post counts.

[Large Dopant white]

QUOTE (vidgms4me @ Sep 6 2003, 10:25 PM)

Oh well, I have no idea where I am going with my arguements.  Just please keep the post counts.

I apoligize if I came off agressive towards you. Perhaps I phrased my wording a bit harshly; nevertheless, I didn't mean to make it seem like I was trying to devolve this into a flame war.

[shavedrat]

I read all the time
I don't post crap replies. (Well, except this one)
I have a low post count.
I must be a noob.

[Timan]

I say keep them on, because when I go shopping in the buy&sell forums, I dont want to be buying from someone with 3 posts, rather feel safer with some active user. also just ignore em if you dont like em :|!

[andrusk]

QUOTE (Timan @ Sep 7 2003, 02:46 AM)

I say keep them on, because when I go shopping in the buy&sell forums, I dont want to be buying from someone with 3 posts, rather feel safer with some active user. also just ignore em if you dont like em :|!

by this definition you might have accidently bought something from anthrax(heaven forbid) and gotton screwed.  

I say keep the post count, but higher the standards of what is acceptable behavior and what is banning material.  In other words, ban more of the morons and keep the post counts.

[rocketman121]

"Bad idea. Because then the newbies will get mixed up with the regulars, and there will be chaos. Keep the post count, I say!"

"I agree with you 100%. However, if you eliminated post counts, there would be no distinction at all. I am well aware that post count does not affect quality advice. Many newbies do give very good advice."

"I say keep them on, because when I go shopping in the buy&sell forums, I dont want to be buying from someone with 3 posts, rather feel safer with some active user. also just ignore em if you dont like em :|!"


If the post count is taken away, you still have the Member Number and Joined date to determine if they are a noob or not.




This post has been edited by rocketman121: Sep 7 2003, 03:43 AM

[KenCuz]

QUOTE (rocketman121 @ Sep 7 2003, 04:12 AM)

EDIT: Why are my quotes not working?

I believe you have to add the date and time also.
QUOTE=vidgms4me,Sep 6 2003, 09:25 PM

QUOTE (vidgms4me @ Sep 6 2003, 09:25 PM)

HI

edit: for the postcount some people should just be banned or have there post count dropped to zero, when they spam. That guy Anthrax spammed the forums to death, he has about ten million posts and joined just a few weeks ago days ago.

This post has been edited by KenCuz: Sep 7 2003, 02:37 AM

[rocketman121]

QUOTE (KenCuz)

I believe you have to add the date and time also. QUOTE=vidgms4me,Sep 6 2003, 09:25 PM QUOTE (vidgms4me @ Sep 6 2003, 09:25 PM) HI

I pretty sure you dont have to.

Click on this link...
http://forums.xbox-scene.com/index.php?act...45&#entry704909

[heinrich]

I think that the post count is fine.  If you see a particular person spamming, bring it to a mods attention.

[feflicker]

I have been here almost a year, very active, and not even got 2000 yet  

edit: ok, looks like I do got 2000 now, 2067 to be exact... didn't even notice