QUOTE(Perplexer @ Feb 2 2007, 05:53 PM)

I'm extremely skeptical of a DVD firmware chip which can be updated from within the console...
Such a chip would need its own O/S in order to facilitate the upgrade. This would also not be transparent to the system, like the current Wii chips are...
WOW. I know twistedsymphony already corrected you on this, but your post could not be any more wrong at all. here is a tech explanation why
If they are tapping in at the DVD's read stream and just buffering the data onto the wii... well, I think they are just tapping into and modifying by holding the line low to make a 0 into a 1 or vs when they detect the DVD mfg id tag, that of course assumes an active-low bus, and that the signal just happens to be changeable in that way. Anyway, point is they can update via DVD. They just set the chip to wait for a specific dvd stream that tells the chip to start updating the firmware with the next XXXX bytes of code.
This would require no OS. Thats just not how hardware works. An OS allows other programs to run without being specifically written for a set of hardware. THIS code is firmware, which of course is/was written for this and only this hardware. Try google.
The problem with that is that, yes retail games 'could' cripple the chip, but only if the code they use is not ciphered. Which is unlikely b/c then other 'scene' releases could use their code on a different chip. So, for a game to disable this chip it would first want to to (unlikely) and then also it would need to know not only the cipher and protocol they used for uploading a firmware image, but also a crc algorithm, the correct dvd stream that tells the chip to start updating, and a new crippled firmware image that would only be effective if it overwrote the bootloader with garbage.
There is also nothing that would make this non-transparent to the hardware. Nothing more then the current chips are.
Your statements that it probably can't update from firmware, that it would need an OS and thus would be visible to the wii are so completely false and that I can only assume you wrote them in your sleep or while very high. Who knows.
edit got twistedsymphony's name wrong