Okay, MooderX, I liked the basic font (it's a gothic font, according to dafont, which I think seemed to go well with the sword), but I switched the color to a deeper red and added a gradient stroke to go along with the lens flare. I thought it made it look like the outside of the text was being lighted up. And yes, my BGs did all look alike (even though I wasn't trying to do that), so it got overhauled.
h34d5h0tz, I changed the lens flare, and it does look better + flipped the sword render. I did a 2 px gradient for the reasons mentioned above, and moved the text so it's more readable.
In addition, after redoing the background, I upped the brightness a little and decreased the contrast, which I thought helped make it look more as if the light was brightening the picture.

Any thoughts on the new version?
Once again, I want to thank you all for your kind words, but especially your criticisms. I definately think I'm much better, and I'm most importantly having a good time.