well heres how i see it.
I know that M$ has a blacklist of Credit Card Numbers, because a friend of mine recently had a problem setting up an xbl acct because he canceled an MSN account at one point. However, this was becasue they considered it a, "nonpaying" card, and the legal problems with a gmaertag discussed later arise if they banned so called, "modded" creditcards.
I also know that it would be horribly illegal of M$ to ban gamertags. Cancell, maybe. But they would have to refund unused time. However, if they really banned the acct, then you wouldnt be able to buy another xbox and play with it.
Lets think this through though, people. They KNOW that a new serial number that was put out years ago isnt going to happen, so all of you 1.4 people who will swear that tey are banning gamertags, you just dont realize how obvious it is when you reflash your eeprom.
There IS a very easily accesible serial number on the hard drives that is not stored on the eeprom. They could have been logging these serial numbers and banning them as they came back. And based on the blacklist of creditcards, this wouldnt be beyond them.
However, if you LEGITIMATELY buy a new xbox, and transfer over your xbl acct using account recovery, I dont see how they can back up banning you. There is nothing illegal about that. Quite frankly, I thikn that the SH*TS who realeased h2 and brought this upon us are going to rot in hell, but its on their souls, not mine.
I am planning on purchasing a new xbox, and running xbl on that one. Nothing except the hdd serial number seems to make sense, and if they ban the new unopened xbox, it would be as easy as bringnig the unopened box to a service station to repair. I have had one instance on the phone where I lied and said that the xbox wasnt opened, but I had bought it used, and they said that if a tech looked at it they could unban it. So its that easy.
looking for a better way to use my remailing 10 mos. of live