I am very thankful for C4Eva and his work as I personally don't know the first thing about XBOX 360 security, nor even how to start coding a firmware to override it. But, on the other side of things, I do have a strong computer programming background and have been working on XBOX consoles since their launch. Which I hope would give me some credibility to what I'm about to say...
First off, I do agree that the boot requirements for 1.6+ firmwares will eventually take their tolls when waves of games come out more frequently. Its only a matter of time before this happens and when it does, making a firmware for each drive will become a daunting of a task for C4Eva and/or others, just like it does now for Hitachi owners. So far in a matter of months since NXE was released, we have seen 3 drive revisions pop up and 2 dashboard updates, allowing for new firmware revisions to be made. Now, if we see a new 'wave' of disc structures every time a new game is released with the NXE update on it, just think of how many new waves will come out in the course of a year? It's much easier for Microsoft and other developers to create a game with a dashboard update on it, than it is to counter the update with a new firmware. And with all of these new features coming out like Facebook, Twitter, last.fm; I'm sure we will see another wave here very soon, making 1.61 obsolete.
Secondly, there is an upside and a downside to creating a firmware (ie. 1.51) that doesn't have strict boot requirements. The upside, we all know, is that we can boot any disc knowing that it will run without use of a bootloader; which can be a good thing for our sake against Microsoft. The downside, however, is that having a firmware that doesn't check the disc is bound to give us (as a scene) some precautions. Just think about all of the users out there who don't rip their own discs, and that don't check their games with ABGX... A lot of people will not know whether or not their games are retail copy of the game or not. Yes, we all know this, and I'm bringing it back up, but eventually Microsoft will adapt to the people who keep playing games that are causing them to get banned. They will make changes that could effect the way we play backups. Is this is a risk that I want to take? Not really? Because I love XBOX 360 hacking, even if I don't understand as much as some people in the scene, I do know that things will get harder and harder to crack and updates will have to come more often than they did in the past.
Sorry for the wall of text, but to the people who are providing suggestions for the firmware; everyone needs to think about why there are requirements in the first place and where this is all going with future NXE releases.
This post has been edited by dharrison: Oct 30 2009, 02:59 PM