Print

[thebroken]

i got nfs today pretty good game my pgr3 should arrive soon cant wait ill let you know which one i like better

[sjw985]

I'm a pretty hard-core sim racer on PC, so interpret my answer within that framework.  Both are totally arcade, but PGR3 to me is a better racing and car control experience.  Also better graphics.  And an actual in-car dash view with good perspective in widescreen (W00T!)  The environments are pretty good too.

NFSMW is (IMHO) complete arcade garbagey port targeted at young kids who dream of ricing out Civics and street racing.  It has a story line where you work your way up through "the blacklist" to gain rep, etc.  It actually held my attention for about an hour, mainly because there was a hot chick in it, then I put it away and haven't been tempted to go back even once.  Driving physics and realism are worse than a joke.

So between the two... PGR3.  But I anxiously await Forza 2, GP3, the next CMR, etc.  Oh yeah and a good FF wheel.  I wonder if my DFP would work?  I should try it...

[darkblizzard]

NFS is better and will continue to always be better

PGR has never seemed any good to me

--- from Gamespot.com --

NFS: 8.4
http://www.gamespot....tml?sid=6140037

PGR: 8.8
http://www.gamespot....tml?sid=6140119

[BoyScout]

depends on what type of game you like... i guess thats final

becuase there both great games but if someone likes real racing games they PGR

if you like some kinda fake racing game where cops follow you around NFS

[darkblizzard]

If you go by the logic of how real something is then Halo wouldnt be the number 1 Xbox game.

[Granulated]

QUOTE(darkblizzard @ Dec 21 2005, 10:41 PM)

If you go by the logic of how real something is then Halo wouldnt be the number 1 Xbox game.

More like Rainbow Six, Tiger Woods, or Forza, then.



Need for Speed is alright once in a while.  UG2 was alright, but I've heard this version is not very good.  I have PGR3 and I love it.  I can almost guarantee it's going to look prettier and be more realistic.  NFSMW is going to be more arcade based.  It just depends on what you like.

[Killa420]

Im not into actual real racing sims so nfsmw would be my choice. I just finished it today finally. Almost cost me a wireless control to. Nothing pisses me off more than racing for 5+ min and when your at the final lap, sometimes final curve, the computer comes flying by and passes you at the last second. My wireless almost went through my window lol.

[Videogamebuyer14]

NFSMW is fun, but way too similar to Midnight Club 3 Dub Ed.

PGR3 is extremely realistic, and very fun.

[BanditRW]

PGR3

[GSX]

PGR3 all the way. NFS is not realistic enough. Atleast thats my opinion.

[crobar]

download the demo for need for speed see how it is...as for pgr3...its a much cleaner and more next gen than NFS...
need for speed is a shitty port, and a shitty game for people who like the pimp their civic and "race"
PGR3 has slick graphics great control and is an overall better experiance

[Satan00]

id say pgr3 because i really didnt like hte fact that i could keep my car on a road turnign at about 190mph, lemme see someone pull that shit in reall ife, or whe ni lfy into the wall at 200mph i just buonce off a bit yo uknow, and sometimes the car looks perfeclty new.. anyawy

pgr3 is the shit, i love the realism and the challenges, if anyone wants to play on live hit me up im always looking for people to play iwth gamertag: stan00

[crobar]

there is no wheel for 360 yet.

[brownboi_nayyar]

Choose PGR3 if you like realistic racing games..

Choose NFS:MW if you like getting chased by cops, souping up your car, etc.

I bought PGR3 though I never really tried out NFS:MW. Download the demo from xbox live market place  

[Tobb555]

PGR3 by miles. Never been a fan of The NFS games because they arnt realistic at all. Im more of a simulation person.