QUOTE(Grim187 @ Aug 30 2009, 12:48 AM)

i doubt that was it, its was probably the tray gears are dirty and it couldent get enough grip to pull the tray all the way back and and lock the spindle/laser assembly in its closed position.
if the problem persists you can clean the gears (remove all the drive casing, tray and logic board and soak the drive in rubbing alcohol) or slide the tray in fast.
I thought it was weird too, but i was disassembling the xbox and was getting frustrated at getting the case apart the second time (i dont have a case tool, made one out of scrap plastic and it sucks) so i was trying to see into the case from the outside with the faceplate off, noticed the tape and figured what the hell, i rememebered reading something that the eject is done through power, not sata and thought it could be a grounding issue and mostly out of frustration used a screwdriver to attach the foil to the case. I didnt expect it to work, but it did.
I suppose that could have been the moving and jostling the case that got it working as well