Yeah i agree, the BenQ drive for me is just as noisy as my Samsung TS-H943 MS28. I think i will play around with both versions of the BenQ fw as it would be nice to have it quiet.
12X on any DVD drive i heard is quite noisy so really i think it is the rotation speed of the disc unless they padded the inner casing more to keep the noise dow...anyway
Hope it gets released tonight though ill be testing it after work tomorrow as i am off to bed

I've had both benQ and samsung (not xbox version but their computer drives). sounds about the same to me...