QUOTE
I have and i do understand but if i know my drive is a ms-25 and i prefer to add my key manually so i can double check it,it would be just as simple just to use the firmware for my drive and copy and paste my cd-key using 360 toolbox thats all i was saying,i dare say after using the cmd a lot of ppl still check their keys in toolbox or keychecker just to be sure
That's totally your choice and their is nothing wrong with that and you can just use any of the ready made firmware .bin files like you said if you want, but what I'm saying is why would you go ahead and do something manually when you have a ready made wizard (which is basically what the Make Extreme Firmware file is) to do it for you (which by the way I'm yet to see screw anyones firmware or drive keys up). I mean Commodore4Eva includes the Make Extreme Firmware file in the package for a reason (simplicity). If it's good enough for him then it's good enough for me
QUOTE
i thought you could just load e.g xtreme52c.bin into xtreme bootmaker and run samhack/read? is that ok or am i talking rubbish? all the tut's i have read dont mention using the makextreme.bat
You can defiinitely just use that method. If you do choose to use the Xtreme Boot Maker and samhack/samread method then you need to remember that you've still gotta choose the appropriate speed firmware for you (A,B,C or D) and then choose the version of that speed firmware that reports the appropiate drive back to your 360, otherwise you risk gettingthe e66 error. Also keep in mind that X360SAM (which is the samhack/samread tool) is the method that the Make Extreme Firmware file uses to create your hacked firmware anyways so you're not gaining any advantage anyways.
The only reason using the Make Extreme Firmware file method has yet to be inlcuded in any tutorials is because either they don't think that it needs to be, because A.) it's very easy to use, B.) the ReadMe clearly explains how to use it, or C.) they just haven't gotten around to it yet.
If you do use the wizard (the Make Extreme Firmware file) you can still always check your hacked firmware with Firmware Toolbox to see if your key is right if you want.