QUOTE(langnao @ Oct 28 2006, 10:37 AM)

For samsung firmware, I would not recommend to use the toolbox to inject the key. Get the xtreme firmware package e.g 4.2 and use the 'make 4.2a' or 'make 4.2b' link from the package to inject the key. It so much easier and less steps to introduce errors.
If it is hitachi drive, even easier, just run the respective batch file to patch...
I think quite a few newbie could have use toolbox wrongly and thus screw up their drive ...
If you are afraid of corruption during dumping of firmware. Dump it twice, and hex byte by byte compare the files, they should be the same. The firmware is 256K in size. And pls, if possible, DON'T use a floppy disk for boot up to flash. It can give you write error when u dump the firmware to the disk and worse still, read error during reading of the hacked firmware to be transfered back to the drive and thus result in failure in flashing ...
First off let me say you are right I agree with you some what but please do not take the rest of this wrong.. its just me comming back to what I was saying ...
First off he has a samsung ms28 ...
toobox in my opinion is great for samsungs (of course 2.0 since it is more up to date)
but for hitachi's you are right.. that is where the errors come from because of the encrypting..not to mention it is not really needed since the patching is done in the release.. so even if you do the encrypting the release just does patching.. you do not use the image with hitachi's.. so yes ALOT of people can screw this up bad...
but for samsung it is great.. for 2 reasons.
IT IS COMPATIBLE
and if the image is corrupted at all toolbox will give you an error. Hence why it is kinda good to just try to open the image just to see (it is just another check)
if it opens then it even shows you your dvd key immediately. And there are no people complaining about toolbox putting in the code in the wrong area... such as KDX which always had issues!!! and still does!!
So yes you are right because it is easier to just have the patching or batch do it for you.. in fact you kinda do not have a choice unless you change things.. which newbs are or should not do.
Since he was wondering if it was good BEFORE doing auto patching and/or batching (which is perfectly fine and recommended anyway) then what I was saying is the way to go.
But you are correct.. the ways you mention are easier because of less steps but not manually checked before hand as I was thinking he/she was asking about.