QUOTE(WBones @ Nov 15 2009, 10:24 PM)
Yeah I'm not sure if 1.51 for Hitachi is completely non-stealth or not but if it is then this theory is blown
These forums are riddled with logical fallacies. How does that "blow the theory"?
Let's assume the following for the purposes of this thread:
- firmware stealth checks can be detected
- invalid stealth data can be detected
- playing early releases can be detected
That would mean:
- perfectly-stealthed discs on stealth-checking firmware can earn you a ban
- improperly-stealthed discs on non-stealth firmware can earn you a ban
- playing early releases on any firmware can earn you a ban
Since there are multiple ways to get banned, you cannot simply say the "theory is blown" just because Hitachi 1.51 users have been banned. You have no way of knowing what they did to get banned in the first place.
The only thing that would "blow the theory" is someone who played perfectly-stealthed discs on non-stealth firmware getting banned. And even then, someone who believes their discs are perfect can be wrong.
On a side note, I wish I had stayed on BenQ 1.41 non-stealth. If I'd known how all this wave shit was going to play out, I'd have never "upgraded" with each firmware update. Microsoft must be laughing mightily if C4E ended up outsmarting himself.