Hmm, if someone says they talked to xbox live, that means they talked to a service rep, thats the only way you could ever say you talked to xbox live unless you sat their and talked to live starter kit.
The guy said you needed 1mb to play the games with no issue. I never said its impossible to do that, just it gets to be an issue, espically in halo 2 were host is everything, and havin a tiny bit of lagg can cause you to miss the final kill ( I would no).
And their is still the issue of if both the boxs are on the 256up and one box starts hoggin the bandwith, the over will be kicked off live. I have not had that issue with my 1mb.
We both agree it is possible, just disagree on the detials of speeds it takes to play a decent game, right?