i dont mind the one you get with the live kit,that damn clip on piece does seem to break easy ive been through 3 in 2 years but ive tried 3 different cell phone head sets and there functionallity vary, either its fine for me but not others in the room or vise versa, peeps complain its either to loud or they cant hear,or i cant hear to well no matter where the volume is set at. they are cheap though they come with the cell phone for free, i havent tried the halo one yet but over all for you and others playing the original seems to be the best but thats just my opinion, im not gonna spend 100.00 on 10 different head sets just to see which is the best for everyone else including myself, id rather buy another xbox to mod, not that i care what others on live say but when you need to comunicate in a game but you get muted by peeps cause your headset disrupts others i just doesnt help, kinda sucks though i have to cats and they have hidden the foam piece that goes on the end of the original,there 3 floating around the apartment, they usually pop up every 2 months or so but they keep taking them and hiding them again anyway, i have to put the mic away at the end of every night, if i forget once its gone by morning