OK, being that I haven't been banned myself (knock on wood), as soon as I heard about the banning's, I immediately pulled my stock HDD out of storage and put it in my XBOX so I could play Halo 2. So far, so good. Whats interesting is I had previously logged onto live using my upgraded HDD months ago.. think the last game I played was Rainbow Six.
Now, if what you say is correct, I should be able to put my upgraded HDD back into my XBOX as long as I:
1. lock it using my unbanned eeprom and hdd key (which it already is and has been since the day I put it in)
2. make sure everything on C: and E: is stock (once again, I never modified anything on C:, E: on the other hand does have saves from emulators and dashboards on it)
3. be 100% the chip is completely off (I use an X2 Pro with the the 4 toggles switches, I have always turned it off before logging onto live)
So, I should be just as good with a upgraded HDD as I am with stock for the following reasons:
1. If they are scanning the LPC for a modchip, they would have gotten me regardless.
2. If they are scanning E: for files that shouldn't be there, they would have noticed the copy of XBMC I have installed there. (yes, I installed it on my stock HDD)
This leads me to believe there is more to the bannings then meets the eye. Someone needs to survey the people who have been banned, and the banned people need to be 100% honest so we can get to bottom of this.
1. Did you lock your upgraded/original HDD before logging onto live?
2. Was you modchip actually turned off?
3. Did you D/L and play the french leak?
3a. If so did you keep the save?
3b. Is the game still on your HDD?
4. What generation modchip are you using? (I ask this becuase it seems people with older modchips haven't been affected at all just from the posts that I've read. Could it be the inclusion of a physical on/off switch is what saved us?)