Well, I got banned the other last week for the very FIRST time, and the chip was off 100% sure. I have an X3, w/ live blocked. MS dash had Autosign in enabled though.
I have a 250Gb HD. It was in there when I set up my Live account over a year ago.
So I replaced the EEPROM, with a fresh one, Im sure because I modded the box it came out of. But I disnt replace the HD.And ran account recovery. I got banned again with the chip off, and this time MS dash auto-sign in was off. It was almost immediately. I logged in, logged off, logged back in, and that was that. I never have had that french game on it, nor any hacked saves. I do use evox trainers, and dashboards are installed on C:\, Apps on E:\, Emus and Games on F:\.
I have another XBOX with an AladdinADV64 and a stock 10 Gb, with F:\ formatted.
Dashboards on C:\, Apps on E:\, nothing on F:\ but it has been partitioned and formatted. This XBOX plays on XBLive with a different gamertag everyday with no probs. And it has all kinds of profiles from that french game.
I am going to flash a new EEPROM tomorrow and install a stock 10gb HD, with only MS files on it, adn see if I can stay on Live.
I also have another XBOX that has never been on Live, with a 120Gb. I am going to set up a fresh account on it tomorrow too.
Will post back with results.